kempersc 3c80de87e0 add isil entries

2025-11-19 23:25:22 +01:00

9.5 KiB

Raw Blame History

Next Session Handoff - G-Class Query Results

Quick Status

Date: 2025-11-16
Session: G-Class Query Execution & Analysis
Status: Analysis complete, ready to update taxonomy

Immediate Action Items

1. Add 13 New Gallery Types to hyponyms_curated.yaml ⚡

File to modify: data/wikidata/hyponyms_curated.yaml

Q-numbers to add (in priority order):

Artist-Run/Cooperative Spaces (⭐⭐⭐ CRITICAL)

Q16020664:
  label: "Canadian artist-run centre"
  description: "galleries and art spaces developed by artists in Canada since the 1960s"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q4034417 (artist-run space) traversal"
  priority: "CRITICAL"

Q4801240:
  label: "artist cooperative"
  description: "visual arts organization jointly owned by its members"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q4034417 (artist-run space) traversal"
  priority: "CRITICAL"

Q3325736:
  label: "artist-run initiative"
  description: "gallery or other facility operated or directed by artists"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q4034417 (artist-run space) traversal"
  priority: "CRITICAL"

Specialized Gallery Types (⭐⭐ HIGH)

Q117072343:
  label: "Jewellery gallery"
  description: "Jewellery gallery"
  alternate_labels: ["Jewelry art gallery", "Jewelry gallery"]
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q1007870 (art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "HIGH"

Q127346204:
  label: "design gallery"
  description: "gallery for design"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q1007870 (art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "HIGH"

Q114023739:
  label: "photographic art gallery"
  description: "photographic art gallery"
  alternate_labels: ["photographic gallery"]
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q1007870 (art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "HIGH"

Institutional Variants (⭐⭐ HIGH)

Q111889841:
  label: "university art museum"
  description: "university art museum"
  alternate_labels: ["university art gallery", "college art gallery", "college art museum"]
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q3196771 (art museum institution) traversal"
  priority: "HIGH"

Q107537774:
  label: "private art museum"
  description: "private art museum"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q3196771 (art museum institution) traversal"
  priority: "HIGH"

Historic/Educational Types (⭐ MEDIUM)

Q3768550:
  label: "plaster cast gallery"
  description: "collection of plaster casts of sculptures"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q1007870 (art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "MEDIUM"

Q29380643:
  label: "cast collection"
  description: "art-historical or archeological collection, usually for education, where copies, usually of gypsum, of art works are collected and shown"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q1007870 (art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "MEDIUM"

Business Model/Specialized Content (⭐ MEDIUM)

Q17111940:
  label: "vanity gallery"
  description: "art gallery that charges artists/promoters for exhibit space"
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q56856618 (commercial art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "MEDIUM"

Q125501487:
  label: "map gallery"
  description: "gallery of maps"
  alternate_labels: ["gallery of maps"]
  discovered: "2025-11-16"
  discovered_via: "Q1007870 (art gallery) traversal"
  priority: "MEDIUM"

2. Regenerate G-Class Query

Script: scripts/generate_gallery_query_with_exclusions.py

Command:

cd /Users/kempersc/apps/glam
python scripts/generate_gallery_query_with_exclusions.py

Expected output:

New query file with 1,832 exclusions (1,819 + 13)
Updated query metadata YAML

3. Review 10 Ambiguous Entities 🤔

File with analysis: data/wikidata/GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN/G/G_CLASS_QUERY_RESULTS_20251116.md

Entities needing review:

Q3458124 - Art galleries in Oostend (geographic category?)
Q2104985 - Centrum Beeldende Kunst (type or instance?)
Q109038036 - Galeries Fnac (corporate brand?)
Q112231820 - Dali museums (→ M-class single-artist museum?)
Q11665453 - Fudoki no oka (→ F or M class?)
Q131538088 - Minka-en (→ M-class open-air museum?)
Q3926588 - Quadreria (Italian term, unclear)
Q135926044 - Phototheque (→ A-class archive?)
Q58482422 - Archives of art collections (→ R or E class?)
Q2293148 - Sculpture trail (→ F-class feature?)

Action for each:

Query additional metadata via Wikidata MCP tool
Check if it's a class (type) or instance (specific entity)
Classify to appropriate GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN class
Document decision

Optional Tasks

4. Document Museum Types for M-Class

38 museum types identified that overlap with G-class query results.

Action: Create note in M-class documentation about these overlaps.

File to create: data/wikidata/GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN/M/M_CLASS_OVERLAPS_FROM_G.md

Content: List of 38 Q-numbers with note:

"These museum types were discovered via art museum (Q207694/Q3196771) traversal during G-class query. They are valid museum subtypes but not galleries. Ensure they are included in M-class base classes or noted as expected results."

5. Execute Next Query Round

After adding 13 new Q-numbers and regenerating query:

Execute simplified query (no exclusions) again
Expect < 75 results (most types now excluded)
Repeat analysis process
Continue until discovery rate < 5%

Files Reference

Created This Session

data/wikidata/GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN/G/G_CLASS_QUERY_RESULTS_20251116.md
- Complete analysis of 75 query results
- Classification decisions
docs/sessions/SESSION_SUMMARY_20251116_G_CLASS_EXECUTION.md
- Full session narrative
- Methodology and findings
data/wikidata/GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN/G/NEXT_SESSION_HANDOFF.md (this file)
- Quick reference for next session

To Modify

data/wikidata/hyponyms_curated.yaml
- Add 13 Q-numbers (see section 1 above)
scripts/generate_gallery_query_with_exclusions.py
- Run to regenerate query

Reference Files

data/wikidata/GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN/G/VERIFIED_Q_NUMBERS.md
- Original 25 Q-number verification from previous session
- Base classes and corrections documented
data/wikidata/GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN/G/queries/gallery_query_updated_20251116T104506.sparql
- Current query (1,819 exclusions)
- Will be replaced after regeneration

Key Decisions Made

Gallery vs. Museum Classification Rule

Rule: If entity has:

✅ Temporary exhibitions focus → Gallery
✅ Sales/commercial function → Gallery
✅ No permanent collection → Gallery

Then classify as G-class.

If entity has:

❌ Permanent collection → Museum
❌ Educational/research mission → Museum
❌ Curated holdings → Museum

Then classify as M-class.

Edge cases:

University art museums → G-class (exhibition spaces in educational settings)
Artist museums → M-class (permanent collections dedicated to one artist)
Private art museums → G-class (private galleries, may sell)

Artist-Run Spaces

Decision: Artist-run spaces are a CRITICAL category for G-class.

Rationale:

Represent significant alternative to commercial/institutional galleries
3 major organizational variants discovered
Growing importance in contemporary art ecosystem

Base class: Q4034417 (artist-run space) validated

Specialized Gallery Types

Decision: Galleries specialized by medium/content are valid G-class types.

Examples:

Jewelry galleries (Q117072343)
Design galleries (Q127346204)
Photography galleries (Q114023739)
Map galleries (Q125501487)

Rationale: Specialization is a key dimension of gallery taxonomy.

Session Metrics

Query execution: 1 successful (simplified query)
Results analyzed: 75 entities (100%)
Valid additions: 13 (17.3% discovery rate)
Coverage estimate: 90-95% of Wikidata gallery types identified
Time spent: ~140 minutes

Questions for Next Session

Should we create separate categories for:
- Artist-run spaces vs. commercial galleries?
- University galleries vs. private galleries?
How to handle museum types in GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN taxonomy:
- Should M-class explicitly exclude art museums?
- Or accept overlap as natural consequence of Wikidata structure?
Geographic variants:
- Should we track regional gallery types separately?
- E.g., Canadian artist-run centres, Dutch Centrum Beeldende Kunst

Tools & Commands

Wikidata MCP Tools Used

# Entity metadata lookup
wikidata-authenticated_get_metadata(entity_id="Q12345", language="en")

# SPARQL query execution
wikidata-authenticated_execute_sparql(sparql_query="SELECT ...")

# Property lookup (for future use)
wikidata-authenticated_get_properties(entity_id="Q12345")

Bash Commands

# Regenerate query
python scripts/generate_gallery_query_with_exclusions.py

# Validate YAML syntax (optional)
python -c "import yaml; yaml.safe_load(open('data/wikidata/hyponyms_curated.yaml'))"

# Count exclusions in YAML
grep -c "^Q[0-9]" data/wikidata/hyponyms_curated.yaml

Contact/References

Previous session summary: docs/sessions/SESSION_SUMMARY_20251116_G_CLASS_VERIFICATION.md
Original agent instructions: AGENTS.md (see "Institution Type Taxonomy" section)
Wikidata query service: https://query.wikidata.org/
GLAMORCUBEPSXHFN taxonomy: 19-type heritage institution classification

Status: ✅ Ready for next session
Blocking issues: None
Time estimate for Task 1: ~30 minutes
Time estimate for Tasks 1-3: ~90 minutes

Good luck! 🚀

9.5 KiB Raw Blame History